Can You Sue for Termite Damage If the Home Was Sold “As Is”

Can You Sue for Termite Damage If the Home Was Sold “As Is”?

/by

The scenario is every homebuyer’s dread: a few months after closing on a property sold “As Is,” a pest control professional delivers the devastating news of a massive, long-term termite infestation with severe structural damage. Many homeowners mistakenly believe that the “As Is” clause means they have no legal recourse and have waived their right to sue. However, in Mississippi, “As Is” protects a seller from many things, but it does not serve as a shield for fraud. If a seller knew about the termite damage, actively hid it, or lied about it on mandatory state disclosure forms, the buyer may still have a strong legal claim for damages.

What Does “As Is” Actually Mean in Mississippi?

To understand your rights, you first need to understand what you actually agreed to. In the world of real estate, an “As Is” clause generally puts the buyer on notice that the seller is offering the property in its current condition, without making any promises to fix defects.

It effectively shifts the burden of inspection to you, the buyer. It says, “What you see is what you get, and it is your job to look closely.”

However, under Mississippi law, the power of an “As Is” clause has limits. It generally applies to:

  • Patent Defects: These are obvious issues that a reasonable inspection would reveal (e.g., a hole in the roof or a broken window).
  • Unknown Latent Defects: Hidden problems that the seller genuinely did not know about.

Significantly, an “As Is” clause does not protect a seller who commits fraud. If a seller possesses specific knowledge of a material defect—like a colony of Formosan termites eating the floor joists—and actively conceals that fact to get the sale to close, the “As Is” clause may be void regarding that specific issue.

The “Silver Bullet” for Buyers: The Mississippi Property Condition Disclosure Statement (PCDS)

Mississippi is a “disclosure state.” Under Mississippi Code § 89-1-501 et seq., sellers of residential property (1 to 4 dwelling units) are legally required to provide a Property Condition Disclosure Statement (PCDS) to the buyer.

This document is not a formality; it is a legal representation of the home’s condition. The seller must answer a series of questions honestly, to the best of their knowledge.

Section D of the standard Mississippi PCDS specifically asks about the History of Infestation. It typically includes questions such as:

  • Are you aware of any past or present problems with termites?
  • Are you aware of any damage caused by termites?
  • Has the property been treated for termites?

If the seller checks “No” on these boxes while secretly knowing the answer is “Yes,” they have committed fraudulent misrepresentation.

In this scenario, the “As Is” clause in your sales contract usually crumbles. A seller cannot use a contract term to waive liability for their own intentional deceit in a statutory disclosure document. If you can prove they lied on this form, you have opened the door to a lawsuit.

Exceptions to the “As Is” Defense: When You Can Sue

Finding termites is not enough to win a lawsuit. To overcome the “As Is” defense, your case generally needs to fall into one of three legal categories:

Fraudulent Misrepresentation (Intentional Fraud)

This is the most common path to victory in termite cases. To prove this under Mississippi law, you must generally demonstrate:

  • The seller made a representation (usually on the PCDS) that was false.
  • The seller knew it was false at the time (this is the key).
  • The seller intended for you to rely on that false statement.
  • You did rely on it (i.e., you bought the house believing it was termite-free).
  • You suffered damages as a result.

Example: The seller paints over water-damaged wood that they know is actually termite damage, then checks “No” on the disclosure form regarding termite history.

Negligent Misrepresentation

Sometimes, a seller might not be maliciously lying, but they are being reckless with the truth. Negligent misrepresentation occurs when a seller makes a factual claim without a reasonable basis for believing it is true.

Example: A seller tells you, “The house was treated for termites last year,” without actually checking their records or verifying with a pest control company. If it turns out the house was not treated and is now infested, they may be liable for that misinformation, even if they didn’t “mean” to lie.

Breach of Contract

Occasionally, specific terms in the purchase agreement might override the general “As Is” language. If the contract explicitly stated that the seller would provide a “clear termite certificate” or repair specific damage before closing, and they failed to do so, you may have a claim for breach of contract.

Proving the Seller Knew: The Evidence You Need

This is the hardest part of any termite litigation case. It is not enough to prove the termites were there before you bought the house; you must prove the seller knew they were there and said nothing.

Since sellers rarely admit to fraud, we have to prove their knowledge through circumstantial evidence. At Reeves & Mestayer, we look for specific “smoking guns”:

  • Cover-Ups: Fresh paint on baseboards that are hollow underneath, new drywall patches over infested studs, or furniture deliberately placed to hide damage during showings.
  • Previous Treatments: We subpoena records from local pest control companies. If we find a report from two years ago stating “Active Infestation found” and the seller never disclosed it, that is powerful evidence of knowledge.
  • Termite Bait Stations: If there are bait stations installed around the perimeter, someone paid for them. If the seller claims they “didn’t know” about termites but were paying a monthly renewal fee for bait stations, their credibility is destroyed.
  • Neighbor Testimony: Neighbors often know the history of a house. A neighbor might say, “Oh yes, the previous owners complained about swarms every spring.”
  • Renovation Records: If the seller remodeled a bathroom recently and the contractor found termite damage, we can depose that contractor to see if they told the homeowner.

The Role of the WDI Report (Wood Destroying Insect Report)

In almost every Mississippi real estate closing involving a lender, a Wood Destroying Insect (WDI) Report is required. This is an official inspection performed by a licensed pest control operator.

This report is critical evidence. It can cut both ways:

  • If the WDI Report found termites: You were on notice. If you bought the house anyway, suing the seller becomes very difficult because you can no longer claim you “relied” on the seller’s statement that there were no termites.
  • If the WDI Report was “Clear”: If the report said “No Visible Evidence,” but there was actually a massive infestation, the focus of your lawsuit might shift (or expand) to the termite inspector.

Can You Sue the Inspector?

Yes. Termite inspectors in Mississippi have a duty to perform a competent inspection according to industry standards. If they missed obvious signs of infestation—mud tubes, damaged wood, or live insects—that a reasonable inspector would have caught, they may be liable for professional negligence.

However, inspectors often try to limit their liability to the cost of the inspection (e.g., $100). Fighting these limitation clauses requires skilled legal arguments about gross negligence or consumer protection violations.

Why “Constructive Fraud” Might Apply to Real Estate Agents

It is not always just the seller. Real estate agents have a duty to treat all parties to a transaction honestly.

If the seller’s agent knew about the termites—perhaps the seller mentioned it in passing, or a previous deal fell through because of a termite inspection—and the agent failed to disclose that material fact to you, the agent and their brokerage could be liable.

In Mississippi, an agent cannot simply repeat a seller’s lie if they have reason to know it is false. This is known as constructive fraud or negligent misrepresentation.

Damages: What Can You Recover?

If your lawsuit is successful, what kind of compensation can you expect? The goal of the court is to “make you whole”—to put you in the financial position you would have been in if the fraud had not occurred.

Common damages in Mississippi termite cases include:

  • Cost of Repairs: The money needed to replace structural beams, drywall, flooring, and siding to restore the home’s integrity.
  • Cost of Treatment: The expense of professional termite extermination and future prevention contracts.
  • Diminished Value: Even after repairs, a home with a history of massive termite damage may be worth less on the market (sometimes called “stigma damage”). You can sue for this difference in value.
  • Temporary Housing: If you have to move out while repairs are being made, you can recover the cost of rent or hotels.
  • Attorney’s Fees: In cases involving fraud or specific contract breaches, the court may order the seller to pay your legal fees.
  • Punitive Damages: If the seller’s conduct was malicious or intentionally fraudulent (e.g., they actively plastered over damage to hide it), the jury may award punitive damages to punish the seller and deter others from doing the same.

What to Do If You Discover Undisclosed Termite Damage

If you peel back a piece of wallpaper and find a swarm, follow these steps immediately:

  • Stop Construction/Repairs: Do not tear out the damaged wood yet. That wood is your evidence.
  • Document Everything: Take high-resolution photos and videos of the damage, the insects, and the surrounding area.
  • Call a Reputable Pest Control Expert: Get a thorough inspection and a written report detailing the extent and age of the damage. You need an expert who can say, “This damage is years old; it was definitely here when the house was sold.”
  • Find Your Closing Documents: Locate your Sales Contract, the Property Condition Disclosure Statement (PCDS), and the WDI Report.
  • Do Not Contact the Seller Yet: Anything you say to the seller (“I think we can work this out”) could be used against you later.
  • Contact a Real Estate Litigation Attorney: You need a lawyer who understands Mississippi property law to review your documents and determine if the “As Is” clause can be pierced.

Get Help from a Mississippi Real Estate Litigation Team

Buying a home is the biggest investment most people make. Finding out that the investment is being eaten from the inside out and that the seller may have tricked you into buying it is a profound violation of trust. While the “As Is” clause is a formidable hurdle, it is not insurmountable. At Reeves & Mestayer, we have extensive experience investigating complex property damage claims. We know how to track down old pest control records, interview witnesses, and build the timeline necessary to prove the seller knew about the infestation.

If you are dealing with undisclosed termite damage in a home you purchased, do not assume you are out of options. Call us at 228-374-5151 or contact us online to schedule your review.